Cheeks flushed pink from glasses of wine near a cozy fire: That simple, luxurious Western New York winter experience is made all the better knowing that what’s in your glass has been thoughtfully produced from just down the road in the Finger Lakes.
Have a conversation with anyone possessing even a passive interest in wine, and there’s one word that’s almost sure to come up: terroir. A literal definition is soil, but when discussing wine, terroir more accurately means time and place. A skilled winemaker endeavors to understand those elements in the fruit that is being farmed, and then correctly represent them in the final, bottled product.
Terroir is an important factor in why a Pinot Noir from Burgundy in France is different than one from Sonoma, Calif., and those are both different than a Pinot Noir produced in New York’s Finger Lakes region. And, yes, the Finger Lakes wine output and reputation are growing—making Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and other varieties along with its world-renowned Rieslings.
People are also reading…
At The Lake House on Canandaigua, a boutique hotel featuring two top-notch restaurants, Director of Food and Beverage Nicholas Massimilian has curated a notably robust wine list to showcase the diverse landscape making up the category that is Finger Lakes wines. While iconic standouts like Chateau Montelena, Chateau Margaux and Tenuta San Guida enjoy representation, there’s no doubt that the list is a kind of love letter to the wines being produced right outside their door. This fall, no fewer than 30 producers were proudly included.
Savor an FLX wine by the firepit at The Lake House on Canandaigua.
Among the most passionate wine professionals advocating for the Finger Lakes region in Buffalo is Daniel Reisch, who was been involved with curating some of the most thoughtful wine lists in the area for decades. He happened upon Hosmer Winery on Cayuga Lake on his way to visit a friend at Cornell 30 years ago, and his appreciation for the wines being produced in the Finger Lakes has only deepened over time. He makes the pilgrimage often, and has noticed that the region is attracting industry professionals from across the country, and around the world.
“These wines are on lists in New York, Chicago and San Francisco,” says Reisch, a senior wine associate at Premier. “These are world-class wines.”
As Reisch sees it, all wine is the product of three basic things (his “Three Ps”): plant, place and people. It’s the people of the winemaking community that are truly unique, and an important component to why the wines here are excelling and garnering such global recognition.
“There’s an interactive and supportive culture of wine making and agriculture that’s unique to the Finger Lakes,” says Reisch. “They help and support each other. And they need our support so we can continue to enjoy this in our own backyard. We have a responsibility to advocate for these wines.”
Another longtime advocate for Finger Lakes wines is Jim Guarino, owner of Shango Bistro on Main Street in Buffalo’s University District. Since Shango opened 17 years ago, it’s enjoyed a reputation for having a thoughtful wine list—where creations from Finger Lakes are always represented. One of the currently featured? A Cabernet Franc, a red grape most associated with France, from Boundary Breaks in Lodi, on Seneca Lake.
Seneca is the deepest of the 11 Finger Lakes, and because it’s so large and deep, it rarely freezes over. The lake moderates the weather conditions, allowing for a more hospitable environment for growing grapes, particularly grapes considered “cool climate” varieties like Riesling, Gewürztraminer and Cabernet Franc.
There are, of course, still the overly sweet, unbalanced and mass-produced wines with which many still associate the region. But more and more truly outstanding and noteworthy wines are gracing wine lists and shelf space. If you’re not already a believer, give one a try. Or better yet, give one to a friend and hope they share it with you by the side of a roaring fire while you watch the snow fall through frosty windows.
Finger Lake standouts
Boundary Breaks Vineyard is also set on Seneca Lake, the deepest of the 11 Finger Lakes.
Boundary Breaks Cabernet Franc
Cabernet Franc is the grape found in Chinon from the Loire Valley in France. It is also a blending grape, commonly associated with Bordeaux. Here it stands alone as an elegant and lean red.
Bloomer Creek Skin Ferment Gewurztraminer/Riesling
Natural wine is buzzing right now, and Bloomer Creek is a pioneer in the movement in New York.
Forge Cellars Railroad Vineyard Dry Riesling
Forge Cellars can be found on renowned wine lists nationwide. This is a bright and lean riesling, perfect for pairing with food.
Nathan Kendall Pinot Noir
An internationally trained winemaker, Nathan Kendall brought his passion and skill to Seneca Lake.
Red Newt Glacier Ridge Vineyard Merlot
Glacier Ridge Vineyard’s moniker is a nod to the glaciers responsible for the creation of the Finger Lakes.
