Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Sweet, scratch-made ice cream sandwiches

Sweet, scratch-made ice cream sandwiches

  • Updated
Ice Cream Sandwiches.jpg

Locally crafted ice cream treats from Churn in North Buffalo (ginger snap coconut), Yummo Ice Cream pop-up (s’mores square) and Cookies & Cream on Seneca St. (Mini M&M).

Keep cool all summer long with these locally crafted, handheld ice cream treats.

Ginger Snap Coconut

Churn | North Buffalo

Churn Ginger Snap Coconut.jpg

Sitting between two artisanal ginger snap cookies is a creamy blend of coconut milk, cane sugar and sea salt. It’s a non-dairy gem that all will enjoy.

Birthday Cake

Fig Tree Patisserie | Kenmore

Handmade macarons and ice cream is a dessert you never knew you needed.

Chocolate Butterfinger

Uncle G’s | Pendleton

Perry’s chocolate ice cream in between two chocolate chip cookies, rolled in Butterfinger crumbs. We thought you wouldn’t object.

Black Raspberry

2 Scoops Ice Cream | Hamburg

For the soft serve lover: a silky raspberry custard and chocolate wafer ice cream sandwich.

S’mores Square

Yummo Ice Cream | Pop-Up

Yummo Smores Square.jpg

Like a klondike bar, but better. This homemade treat is gourmet all the way with a caramelized graham cracker center and extra toasted marshmallow ice cream, all encased in a dark-milk chocolate shell and sprinkled with smoked sea salt.

Cinnamon Pinwheel

Rosie’s Handcrafted Ice Cream | East Aurora

Housemade cream cheese ice cream surrounded by cinnamon pinwheel cookies.

Strawberries & Cream

Lake Effect | Lockport & North Buffalo

This homemade ice cream bar is the strawberries and cream of our dreams, made with local ingredients.

Orange Chocolate

Platter’s Chocolates | North Tonawanda

When you’re known for homemade orange chocolate, turning it into an orange chocolate ice cream sandwich is a no brainer.

Choco Taco

Hydraulic Hearth | Buffalo

Is a taco a sandwich? Try this crunchy, salty yet sweet homemade novelty and let us know.


Adrian’s Beef & Custard | Grand Island

Homemade funfetti cookies with your choice of Perry’s ice cream is a sandwich worth crossing waterways.

Mini M&M

Cookies & Cream | Buffalo

Cookies & Cream Mini M&M.jpg

A giant cookie sandwich made with freshly baked mini M&M cookies, your ice cream of choice and a signature sprinkle blend.


Ballyhoo | Buffalo

The classic sandwich of your childhood just got turned all the way up with this combo of soft, thin homemade chocolate chip cookies and a generous serving of vanilla ice cream.

Cookie Monster Creamy Bun

Poutine & Cream | North Buffalo

Yes, a donut ice cream sandwich exists. Here, a warm donut spoons homemade cookies and cream ice cream, topped with crumbled Oreos and Chips Ahoy.

Citrus Got Real

Nickel City Vice | Kenmore

Try this nostalgic twist: Homemade Fruity Pebbles cereal milk ice cream is sandwiched between two Fruity Pebble rice krispies. Bonus, it’s gluten free.

Treat yo’self

Cookies & Cream.jpg

Step 1: ID your ice cream. Show off and make your own ice cream at home, or pick up your favorite flavor at the store.

Step 2: Soften for 10 mins. Stir and spread out into an even layer in a saran wrap-lined baking sheet.

Step 3: Freeze. For 3-24 hours. Trust us, don’t rush this one.

Step 4: ID your shell. Bake a sheet or buy your favorite cookies. Or melt some chocolate for dipping.

Step 5: Cut & assemble. Stack for a sandwich. Dunk for a bar.

Step 6: Freeze again. For 24 hours this time. Sorry.

Step 7: Bite in. Keep frozen in a freezer-safe bag for up to three months.

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story